Joseph is often described as a snotty little upstart, a gossip and tattletale who brings an evil report about his brothers back to his father. I think that misses the whole tone of the story. Joseph is the “foreman” of his brothers (at the age of 17!), a younger son elevated above his brothers. He is, as one of my students put it, “chief shepherd.”
If Joseph is a tattletale, we also miss just how crude and violent his brothers were. Think about their track record: They envy their father’s favorite, intend to kill him, sell him into slavery, and then lie to their father for years about it. This is not merely a sin against Joseph but a horrible sin against their father. Reuben, we discover later, sleeps with his father’s concubine, and Simeon and Levi slaughter the peaceable, circumcised people of Shechem.
This is a violent, deceptive, cruel bunch. Yet commentators spend their time criticizing Joseph ?
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
The Possibility of Possibility
"Might could” is a Southern expression meaning “maybe I could” or “I might be able to,” conveying…
The False Promise of No Contact
Around the time nineteen-year-old Alice began cutting ties with her family, she announced on social media that…
Moral Certitude and the Iran War
The current military engagement with Iran calls renewed attention to just war theory in the Catholic tradition.…
