Conflation?

Stephen Finlan (The Background and Contents of Paul’s Cultic Atonement Metaphors) thinks that Paul mixes his metaphors:

“Paul indicates that
salvation is not free: ‘you were bought with a price’ (1 Cor 6:20; 7:23).
Here, the Christian gets a new owner: Christ. The death of Jesus functioned as
legal tender to make this purchase. In Rom 3:24–25 we have justification,
redemption, and place of atonement—a conflation of judicial, economic,
and sacrificial imagery. Paul will move from one metaphor to the other, but
always there is a transaction by which salvation is purchased, arranged, or ritually obtained for us” (5).

Finlan lists four metaphorical spheres: sacrifice, “curse transmission ritual,” redemption, and martyrdom. 

But these are “conflated” only if we begin from the assumption that they are separable spheres of action or thought. What if for Paul sacrifice was also redemption, or that it was a curse transmission ritual precisely because it was a martyrdom? In that case, Paul is not conflating metaphors; when he talks about being bought by Jesus’ death, he is simply describing one dimension of sacrifice. 

Perhaps – and it is only a perhaps – we see conflation of distinct realms where Paul did not. Perhaps in his ancient Jewish mind these were always already entangled.

Next
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Lift My Chin, Lord 

Jennifer Reeser

Lift my chin, Lord,Say to me,“You are not whoYou feared to be,Not Hecate, quite,With howling sound,Torch held…

Letters

Two delightful essays in the March issue, by Nikolas Prassas (“Large Language Poetry,” March 2025) and Gary…

Spring Twilight After Penance 

Sally Thomas

Let’s say you’ve just comeFrom confession. Late sunPours through the budding treesThat mark the brown creek washing Itself…