American priestcraft

Was the American Revolution inspired by the Enlightenment? Or was it an evangelical Presbyterian rebellion?

One way to get at that would be to examine the rhetoric concerning “priestcraft” in the American revolution. More than forty years ago, Carl Bridenbaugh pointed to the importance of debates about Anglicanism in the American revolution, and perhaps examining those debates could reveal how much the American revolutionaries were indebted to Enlightenment anti-clericalism.

One also notes the anti-priestly rhetoric and impulse that lies behind many of the most characteristically American religious forms, growing out of revivalism.

At the very least, American evangelicalism and European Enlightenment have a common animus toward priestcraft.