Modernity rests on a distinction between Us moderns and Them primitives. Them primitive might be dead and gone; they might be somewhere south of Us, in warmer, wetter climates and with darker skin. But Them is primitive, even if they are contemporaries.
The problem is, modernity spawns a continuous streams of new Us’s. Modernity is novelty, and the newer the novelty the better. Each new novelty renders the last novelty old-fashioned. Each novelty creates a new Them to contrast with Us avant-gardists, Us true moderns.
Modernity thus continuous transgresses the bounds of modernity, continuously surpasses itself. Modernity is at its essence a machine for producing the post-modern.
Our Most Popular Articles of 2025
It’s been a big year for First Things. Our website was completely redesigned, and stories like the…
Our Year in Film & Television—2025
First Things editors and writers share the most memorable films and TV shows they watched this year.…
Religious Freedom Is the Soul of American Security
In the quiet sanctuary of West Point’s Old Cadet Chapel, a striking mural crowns the apse above…