At least Thiselton gets James Barr right. Asked about the meaning of ekklesia in the New Testament, “we might say (a) ‘the Church is the Body of Christ’ (b) ‘the Church is the first installment of the Kingdom of God’ (c) ‘the Church is the Bride of Christ, and other such statements. In one sense Barr concedes, this is the ‘meaning of “church.”’ But it is certainly not ‘the meaning of ‘church’ in Matt. 16.18 .”
Exactly: Totality transfer is a fallacy about word usage, not about concepts. Barr agrees that one can properly compile all the uses of a term, and related terms, in the Bible, and come up with the total biblical concept. The error comes when we assume that that total concept is the meaning of the word in every context where it is used.
Grow the concept as big as you please, Barr says; just don’t try to stuff it into the small space occupied by the word in a particular passage.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
Of Roots and Adventures
I have lived in Ohio, Michigan, Georgia (twice), Pennsylvania, Alabama (also twice), England, and Idaho. I left…
Our Most Popular Articles of 2025
It’s been a big year for First Things. Our website was completely redesigned, and stories like the…
Our Year in Film & Television—2025
First Things editors and writers share the most memorable films and TV shows they watched this year.…
