Which Party Of John C. Calhoun?

This line from Sam Tanenhaus’s article on the “original sin” of conservatism jumped out at me:

Calhoun’s innovation was to develop a radical theory of minority-interest democracy based on his mastery of the Constitution’s quirky arithmetic, which often subordinated the will of the many to the settled prejudices of the few.

Near as I can tell, John C. Calhoun is periodically reincarnated, and most recently as Harry Blackmun.  Tanenhaus would be better off if he either thought more deeply about, or else let alone questions of “the Constitution’s quirky arithmetic” allowing policy to be made according to “the settled prejudices of the few.”  Yes, I know Blackmun was a Republican, but his ideological descendants aren’t.

Next
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Of Roots and Adventures

Peter J. Leithart

I have lived in Ohio, Michigan, Georgia (twice), Pennsylvania, Alabama (also twice), England, and Idaho. I left…

Our Most Popular Articles of 2025

The Editors

It’s been a big year for First Things. Our website was completely redesigned, and stories like the…

Our Year in Film & Television—2025

Various

First Things editors and writers share the most memorable films and TV shows they watched this year.…