Peace in a Humbler Form

As we anticipate Advent and a month of preparation for the birthday of the Prince of Peace, it’s good to reflect on the peace of Christ and its relationship to another form of peace in a world riven by aggression and war. 

In The City of God, St. Augustine taught that the peace of which this world is capable is well-ordered concord or tranquillitas ordinis, the “tranquillity of order.” What exactly might that mean today? A look at some of the places where conflict remains but conflicts are resolved peacefully suggests some twenty-first-century answers.

The peace of “order” certainly includes precisely that: public order, based on the just application of just laws. That kind of order is typically found in free societies, where the governed exercise their inalienable right to consent to the laws by which they are governed. There may be “order” of a sort in China, North Korea, and Russia; but it is an “order” enforced by repression of public opinion and, not infrequently, by violence, even murder. There is no “tranquillity of order” or “peace” in Augustine’s sense of the term under totalitarian regimes. 

So the peace of “order” must include justice and freedom. How is that peace established, within and among states?

Within states, the peace of order can evolve over time, as it has in most democracies. That is why every democracy is an ongoing experiment. As John Paul II taught in the 1991 social encyclical Centesimus Annus, it takes a critical mass of people, living certain virtues, to make politics, law, and markets—the machinery of political and economic freedom—work so that individuals can flourish within the bonds of social solidarity. 

The peace of order can also be imposed on states. That is what the United States and its allies did with Germany, and what the United States did in Japan, after World War II. Following the defeat of aggression, the Allied occupation of Germany and the American occupation of Japan created the conditions for the possibility of those states to develop the institutions and mechanisms of political and economic freedom: to build the peace of order within their states so that those states would no longer be, as they had been, instruments of peace-breaking internationally. American security guarantees then allowed those states to function within an alliance system in which there were all sorts of conflicts, but those conflicts were resolved without resort to war. 

To take one example: France and Germany, the West Franks and the East Franks of Charlemagne’s old empire, were in conflict for centuries. Those conflicts almost destroyed Europe twice in the twentieth century. The peace of order that exists between Germany and France today—the fact that it is virtually inconceivable that these two states could have at each other as they did in 1914–18 and 1939–45—is not the result of the French or the Germans being transformed into angels. Yes, attitudes have changed and ancient prejudices have been modified. But peace between these once-warring enemies is the result of more than an outbreak of empathy. It is the result of a thick web of political and economic relationships, translated into the legal instrument of treaties, that allow ongoing conflicts to be processed and adjudicated by means other than armies, navies, and air forces. The same might be said about the relationship between Japan and many of the neighboring East Asian states it once sought to enfold in a de facto imperial system, the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere.  

This peace of order is a humbler sort of peace than the peace of Christ, or the Kingdom-peace of a world in which lions lie with lambs. The peace of Christ, which comes from friendship with the incarnate Son of God, and the shalom vision of Isaiah 11:6 can inform and inspire our efforts to build the peace of order, in and among states. I think that’s why that haunting, inspiring chorale, “The Dream Isaiah Saw,” composed in the aftermath of 9/11, has become one of the most popular of Christmas-season songs. 

As St. Augustine and the long tradition of Catholic international relations theory conceive it, however, peace in this world can and must be built before swords are beaten into plowshares. Indeed, swords are sometimes needed to ensure that the plowshares can do their peaceful work. Ukraine knows this. So should the rest of us, even as we work to see that the necessity of using the sword is minimized and the damage swords cause is constrained, when it is necessary to use the sword to vindicate just causes, as it surely is in Ukraine.


George Weigel’s column “The Catholic Difference” is syndicated by the Denver Catholic, the official publication of the Archdiocese of Denver.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Vance Vance Devolution

The Editors

The editors discuss the Jensen Huang scandal, the uncertain future of the “new right,” and whether the…

Realism and Reunion

Michael Root

Ecumenism has, to put it mildly, stalled. Since the beginning of this century, efforts aimed at bringing…

Form vs. Monsters

Glenn C. Arbery

The nature and aims of Catholic fiction have been a matter of debate for generations now. What…