Mutable holiness

Augustine on visible words again: Verbs change in sound and visual sign when they are referring to the same event at different times; a future verb and a past verb refer to the same thing, but the sign changes. So too do sacraments: Christ’s future coming is announced by one set of signs, the fulfillment of that promise by another set ( quid mirum si aliis mysteriorum signaculis passio et resurrectio Christi futura promissa est, aliis iam facta annuntiatur ).

This implies that sacraments are changeable and temporal ( mutabilia et temporalia ), albeit they are sacrosancta . They are changeable and temporal not only because of the shift from Old to New, but because the actions of sacred rites are like the sounds of words – “they sound and pass away.”

I wonder: Did anyone before Augustine (or, before Christianity) suggest that the sacrosancta might be mutabilia et temporalia ?

Next
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Christians Are Reclaiming Marriage to Protect Children

Katy Faust

Gay marriage did not merely redefine an institution. It created child victims. After ten years, a coalition…

Save the Fox, Kill the Fetus

Carl R. Trueman

Question: Why do babies in the womb have fewer rights than vermin? Answer: Because men can buy…

The Battle of Minneapolis

Pavlos Papadopoulos

The Battle of Minneapolis is the latest flashpoint in our ongoing regime-level political conflict. It pits not…