For an English Teacher 

You died, but it was not your words that faltered. 
You’d husbanded the language all your life, 
And when at last your friends and students met
To share a few brief speeches, nothing had altered. 
A constant wife 
Turned constant widow, English loved you yet.
You used to tell us, when an essay missed
Your mark, that we
Would fail more frequently than language would—
Still, just today some New York columnist
Was fretting at the inability 
Of words to make his feelings understood.
An idiot. I read his grievance through 
Once more with pen in hand, just for the fun 
Of citing every petulant detail 
Over the phone sarcastically to you. 
I’d just begun 
To dial when I remembered. Words did not fail. 

—Matthew Buckley Smith

Next
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

What We’ve Been Reading—Autumn 2025

The Editors

First Things staff share their most recent autumn reading recommendations.

Walker Percy’s Pilgrimage

Algis Valiunas

People can get used to most anything. Even the abyss may be rendered tolerable—or, for that matter,…

Outgrowing Nostalgia in The Ballad of Wallis Island

Peter J. Leithart

No man is an island,” John Donne declares in his Devotions upon Emergent Occasions. The Ballad of…