A reader sends this story along: Johns Hopkins has completed a 5-way kidney swap, in which five people gave their organs to unrelated people. But it wasn’t pure altruism. It was a barter deal. In return for giving a kidney to an unrelated person, another donor gave a kidney to the first donor’s loved one, and so on down the line five times. In other words, five persons reached a contract of sorts to donate a kidney to each others’ family members so that their own loved one could receive a transplant.
Federal law prohibits, as it should, the buying and selling of organs. But this was, in its own way, a commercial transaction—with the consideration being an organ rather than legal tender. And the surgeries were apparently rushed so that no donor could change their mind about having a kidney removed once their family member received a transplant. Love can be a greater incentive than money, as we all know. Given that these donations can result in the debilitation or death of the living donor, I think we should be wary of such transactions.
HT: F. White
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
How the State Failed Noelia Castillo
On March 26, Noelia Castillo, a twenty-five-year-old Spanish woman, was killed by her doctors at her own…
The Mind’s Profane and Sacred Loves
The teachers you have make all the difference in your life. That they happened to come into…
History’s Pro Tips on Iran
Nothing in human experience compares to the wars of the last 120 years. Their scope has grown…
