Dutch TV Contestants Vie for Kidney


The Dutch continue to stun with their fall off a vertical bioethical cliff: In this installment, a television show will soon air in which three ill contestants vie for the right to the kidney of a terminally ill woman. From the story in the UK’s Guardian:

In the show, due to be broadcast on Friday, a woman identified only as Lisa, 37, will select a recipient based on their history, profile and conversations with their families and friends. Throughout the 80-minute show, viewers will be invited to send Lisa text messages to advise her.

This is voyeurism on a scale that boggles the mind. It turns the serious issue of the ethics of organ transplant into a game show. It denies intrinsic human dignity in that it pits desperate people against each other, clawing and kicking—metaphorically speaking—for life. What kind of a physician would be willing to be part of such a spectacle?

Hey! Here’s an idea: Maybe in the next show they can tie the organ contest with a televised assisted suicide! That would garner the ratings.

But, why worry: It’s just “choice,” right?

Next
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Wassailing at Christmas

Francis Young

Every year on January 17, revelers gather in an orchard near the Butcher’s Arms in the Somerset…

Rome and the Church in the United States

George Weigel

Archbishop Michael J. Curley of Baltimore, who confirmed my father, was a pugnacious Irishman with a taste…

Marriage Annulment and False Mercy

Luma Simms

Pope Leo XIV recently told participants in a juridical-pastoral formation course of the Roman Rota that the…