Individual and other

I cannot be the particular individual I am without particular others (parents, teachers, friends, etc.). The others might have been other others (different parents, e.g.) but then I would be a different particular individual.

But I cannot be an individual at all without being a particular individual.

So, I cannot be particular without others.

There is no irreducibility without relation.

But of course, there is no relation without irreducible difference either. If I am not other than others, I am the same, and only self-related.

My irreducible uniqueness and my relations are not two things that need to be “balanced” on each side of a fulcrum. They constitute and define each other, and neither makes sense without the other.

We’re glad you’re enjoying First Things

Create an account below to continue reading.

Or, subscribe for full unlimited access

 

Already a have an account? Sign In