Goats Are Not Property

A story of old Irish hero Daniel O’Connell, quoted in Sean O’Faolain’s biography :

I remember I was once counsel before Judge Day for a man who had stolen some goats. The fact was proved; whereupon I produced to old Day an old Act of Parliament, empowering the owners of cornfields, gardens, or plantations to kill and destroy all goats trespassing thereon. I contended that this legal power of destruction clearly demonstrated that goats were not property ; and I thence inferred that the stealer of goats was not legally a thief, nor punishable as such. Poor Day charged the jury accordingly, and the prisoner was acquitted.

We’re glad you’re enjoying First Things

Create an account below to continue reading.

Or, subscribe for full unlimited access

 

Already a have an account? Sign In