Support First Things by turning your adblocker off or by making a  donation. Thanks!

The Return of Jean

From First Thoughts

Jean wrote this morning. I haven’t gotten her permission to post her astute comments. But I will mention a couple of points: Jean is right that it’s pretty misleading to lump LOCHNER with ROE and DRED SCOTT as substantive due process evildoing. The issue in LOCHNER is something over . . . . Continue Reading »

TR and Progress: A Third View

From First Thoughts

So having read Bob’s post and Carl’s very thorough and elegant response, let me offer a somewhat different view on the relationship between the progessive TR and our (new kind of) progressive Justice Anthony Kennedy. So TR and TK are both about constitutional development, that’s . . . . Continue Reading »

More TR Studies: Bob Patterson Weighs in

From First Thoughts

Here is Bob’s spirited reponse to all the Teddy bashing we’ve had on this channel: It came as no surprise that my interlocutors in a recent Claremont Institute symposium, following in the tradition of Leo Strauss, are no fans of Theodore Roosevelt. But things went a little far when the . . . . Continue Reading »

More TR Studies: Family Values

From First Thoughts

Here is a conversation on the Claremont Review site . It’s basically Jean and Scott Yenor (who wrote a great book on the family and modern political philosophy) vs. Bob Patterson (former editor of the impressive journal THE FAMILY IN AMERICA). To repeat myself, I’m with Jean that . . . . Continue Reading »