SUBSCRIBER LOGIN

Search
First Things

Loading

RSS

Masthead

Recent Comments

  • teleologist: Thanks you for the opportunity to express our opinions with the time that we had. Tongues will cease,...
  • Orthodoxdj: As Tolkien said to Lewis as they parted on that fateful night in Oxford, “Goodbye.”
  • Livingston Dell: I didn’t always comment as frequently as I had liked to on these articles, but I always...
  • Nikolai Volk: You know, we had a hell of a run in these comment sections. I’ve had many a great discussion with...
  • David Strunk: Hey Joe, I also appreciated what you guys did here, and always had this blog on my RSS feed to see the...
  • Amy K. Hall: Thanks for starting the blog, Joe. It was an honor to be included.
  • Archives

    Categories

    Monthly


    « Previous  |Home|  Next »         

    Wednesday, December 30, 2009, 8:53 AM

    Muslims and non-Muslims who live in nations where Islam is not the law of the land talk a lot about how Islam is a religion of peace and tolerance. Christians who live in Islamic nations tell a different story. I picked this up from Ron Dreher’s blog, who writes: “If you want to know what it’s really like to live under persecution for your Christian faith and culture, listen to this presentation by Bishop Thomas, a Copt who serves in Assiut, an area of intense Islamic persecution of Christians. I met him once, and the man is so luminous, and peaceful. It’s almost humiliating to be an American Christian, with such an easy life despite it all, and to hear what life is like for Christians in Egypt and elsewhere. If you don’t have time to watch the whole nine minute video, start at about 2:45:

    6 Comments

      The Myth of Islamic Tolerance | Evangel « Read.Think.Pray.Live.Serve.
      December 30th, 2009 | 12:55 pm | #1

      [...] [via Evangel] [...]

      Blue Collar Todd
      December 30th, 2009 | 2:02 pm | #2

      People also fail to understand that Islam, and therefore Muslims, reject any distinction between the Mosque and the State. It is a Totalitarian world view that wants to impose Shariah Law on a global scale. Also, the Liberal appeasement of Islam is a danger to Democracy. When feminists defend the wearing of the burka, something has gone terribly wrong.

      Coyle
      December 30th, 2009 | 3:58 pm | #3

      I think this might be an apt comparison: Islam is to tolerance what Christianity is to violence. You can squeeze it out of their central texts (people certainly have historically), but you have to work to do it, and it never lasts long or ends well…

      Gary Simmons
      December 30th, 2009 | 7:19 pm | #4

      There’s not much in the actions of Jesus that are inherently violent.

      Does God use violence in Christian belief? Yes. Did God ever call His followers to go to war? Only in the context of the covenant of Genesis 12. Unless it’s the conquest of Canaan, it’s not valid. That holy war was a unique event not to be repeated as a “tradition.” The “tradition” stopped in Judges 2.

      Daryl Little
      December 30th, 2009 | 11:01 pm | #5

      I think it’s a stretch to say that “holy war” stopped being legitimate at Judges 2, but certainly it’s out of bounds since God stopped telling us what to do on a given day.

      I like what Coyle said. It really boils down to the fact that in Christianity, it’s those who are truly being (or trying to be) faithful to Scripture who repudiate violence as a means of advancing the Kingdom. In Islam, it’s those who are trying to be faithful to their “Scripture” who embrace violence as a (primary) means of advancing their kingdom.

      Nicodemus
      January 1st, 2010 | 4:30 pm | #6

      I would recommend the Hudson Institute’s monogram entitled,

      http://www.currenttrends.org/docLib/20091110_IntheShadowsoftheKoran.pdf

      In the Shadows
      of the Koran: Said
      Qutb’s Views on
      Jews and Christians
      as Reflected in his
      Koran Commentary
      by MICHAEL EBSTEIN

      Michael Ebstein says that Said Qutb’s influence among Islamic fundamentalist movements of the modern era is profound and so this is well worth a read. The role of “dhimma” is particularly enlightening in the context of this blog article.For those interested the address is above but I am also reviewing it slowly on my blog and it can be found in my section under the label “Islam” on the right.

      What I am particularly interested in is what can be done about all this that is constructive and helpful for the cause of peace, or can there be any peace?

    Links

    Blogs

    Find Us

    Contact