SUBSCRIBER LOGIN

Search
First Things

Loading

RSS

Masthead

Recent Comments

  • teleologist: Thanks you for the opportunity to express our opinions with the time that we had. Tongues will cease,...
  • Orthodoxdj: As Tolkien said to Lewis as they parted on that fateful night in Oxford, “Goodbye.”
  • Livingston Dell: I didn’t always comment as frequently as I had liked to on these articles, but I always...
  • Nikolai Volk: You know, we had a hell of a run in these comment sections. I’ve had many a great discussion with...
  • David Strunk: Hey Joe, I also appreciated what you guys did here, and always had this blog on my RSS feed to see the...
  • Amy K. Hall: Thanks for starting the blog, Joe. It was an honor to be included.
  • Archives

    Categories

    Monthly


    « Previous  |Home|  Next »         

    Sunday, November 8, 2009, 9:49 PM

    Years ago, when I saw Beauty and the Beast on Broadway, I had heard John Mark’s thoughts on the Disney story (and agreed), so I was pleasantly surprised when a song came out of nowhere–a song that doesn’t appear on any of the soundtracks (film or musical)–when Belle leaves the Beast and returns to her village to help her father.  Here’s an excerpt:

    And I– I never thought I’d leave behind
    My childhood dreams
    But I don’t mind
    For now I love the world I see
    No change of heart a change in me

    For in my dark despair
    I slowly understood
    My perfect world out there
    Had disappeared for good
    But in it’s place I feel
    A truer life begin
    And it’s so good and real
    It must come from within

    And I– I never thought I’d leave behind
    My childhood dreams but I don’t mind
    I’m where and who I want to be
    No change of heart
    A change in me

    So there you have it.  Hidden amongst somewhat nonsensical lyrics and some vague heresy about “good and real” things coming “from within,” there’s repentance from Belle for longing for “much more than this provincial life.”  She calls her former demands for a perfect world a “childhood dream,” and she finally finds in her humble village the kind of love, contentment, and “true life” that the Beauty of the original fairy tale never lacked.  It’s worth noting that only after this change in Belle is she able to redeem the Beast with her love.

    3 Comments

      Jeremy Pierce
      November 9th, 2009 | 7:04 am | #1

      This reminds me of when Eowyn recants and marries Faramir, seeing the traditional role of wife and mother as worthy of pursuit after all, something Peter Jackson completely ignored. I doubt it was deliberate, but he was probably just completely tone-deaf to what Tolkien was doing. The idea that women can have fulfilling lives and be serving the ultimate good while not trying to be exactly like men just has no place in his world.

      J. Bob
      November 9th, 2009 | 10:51 am | #2

      Jeremy, that is also one of my favorite parts of Tolkein’s, Middle Earth’s writings.

      John Mark Reynolds
      November 9th, 2009 | 10:59 am | #3

      That is a very exciting find . . . and would have improved an already great movie!

    Links

    Blogs

    Find Us

    Contact